Churches – Large and Small
There has been a debate for some time about whether a small church or large church is the best place to be. I can only talk about my experiences. Over the past several decades we have seen the development of mega churches... particularly in the evangelical community. Some see this as an impediment to the church actually fulfilling it's function in the world and other see it as the way the church really should be working.
Those who choose to attend a more local community church appreciate knowing pretty much every one in the body. This is the kind of church I grew up in and the music was generally the hymns of the church that brought comfort to the members in times of trouble and joy. People pitched in when there was a need. We lived in rural Pennsylvania at the time and there was a family in a neighboring church whose barn was burned to the ground. The members of their church got together and built them another one.
These organizations were run by a pastor and a fairly small staff with member volunteers handling most of the work. At times these volunteers confused their opinion with biblical mandate and an occasional squabble would arise. Often they were resolved with a few ruffled feathers, but at times, they led to factions going their own separate ways.
On the other hand, some churches turned their focus outward, looking beyond the scope of their current membership to those in the area that had no connection to their Creator. Most of the time there was a genuine concern for the lost neighbors, even though a few ego driven, numbers seeking leaders were more concerned about building their brand and status.
Whether real, imagined, or statistically driven, changes were made to the operation of these churches as they desired to bring in new people. Leaders believed people would be put off by “old fashioned” church music. (I discussed here this a few weeks ago) They have substituted theologically correct but sometimes musically lacking contemporary worship music that often contains much repetition – as in helping newcomers get a few things settled in their minds. The “sermon” became a “Bible study”. “Sunday school” became a variety of names... I think the current term at my church is “life group”
Bible studies did not go as deep as before and are often geared to the new comer, or “seeker”. Those desiring an better knowledge of the Word of God were encouraged to go to their life group or other classes scheduled to help the new believer grow.
All these changes are enough to encourage those looking for a traditional body where they can feel comfortable to find such churches in the area. Some church growth gurus believe this is a good thing. I'm not sure making any members, new or old, feel unwelcome is the best idea. Most others accept the changes, some with enthusiasm and other grudgingly.
So, is this a good thing or not? I can't speak for all mega churches, only the one that I am part of. There are some inconveniences to the old members and many of the new members don't appreciate what has gone on before. With the steady steam of new music coming along they may never have the kind of connection we had to the John Newton and Amazing Grace or even Bill Gaither and He Touched Me.
With all the seeming negatives with a large church bringing people in from the community, are the benefits that keep people coming back, even when everything is not completely to their liking?
For me, the benefits can be summed up in one number. Six hundred and fifty people were baptized last year, some in the auditorium (not sanctuary any more) of my church and some on the beach of the Gulf of America. That is six hundred and fifty people who decided to accept the salvation offered by the blood of Jesus. For those who think that is no big deal – and there are churches who have seen much larger results – it comes down to the purpose of the church – making and descipling new believers.
Considering the eternal implications of the decision, THIS IS the mission of the church.
Despite the disruption of the traditional worship, our life group, or whatever we call it this year, is a place where we get to know each other, pray with each other and help each other when there is a need. As with the smaller churches, most of the work is done by member volunteers. Of course the paid staff is much larger, but so is the need and the things that have to be done, so there is plenty of opportunity to volunteer in the area that most closely fits you interest and skills.
When I look at the multi-million dollar budget, I can see that my little contribution doesn't mean that much – but if everyone thought that way, nothing would get done. So every contribution means something. When we all do our part, good things happen. I can deal with the first half hour of the Sunday service and listen to music that speaks to me at home.
As Charlie Martin has said: You have to keep the main thing the main thing.